Bird In The Hand? – Selling Bankruptcy Claims – Michael Dennis, CBF

Bird In Hand, Worth Two in Bush

CMA Note: This is the first post in a new blog series authored by Michael Dennis, CBF called Covering Credit Commentary. Michael will be posting every Thursday sharing his viewpoint and personal experience on aspects of business credit, career advancement, leadership and collections. We hope you enjoy this new blog series and encourage you to comment on the posts to increase the conversation.

A friend of mine asked me what I thought about selling claims in bankruptcy to a third party company purchasing claims from unsecured creditors.  I responded that I have always convinced my employers not to do so.  He said he was considering it, pointing out that he would have payment within ten days.  I agree that one of the main reasons that companies sell their claims in bankruptcy is the proverbial Bird in the Hand argument — meaning that you get your money sooner rather than later.

However, I also believe that all of the following facts are true.  These buyers are in business to make a profit.  Therefore, the amount they offer you will be and must be significantly less than the amount they expect to receive from the debtor.  Also, these companies usually reserve the right, but not the obligation, to purchase any other bankruptcy claims approved by the court for whatever percent you originally agreed to accept for your unsecured claim.  This would include secured claims for which you as a creditor could expect to receive 100 cents on the dollar.

Another concern I have is the contract that must be signed before you receive payment.   At least one contract I received and read recently stated that the sale was being made with recourse.  This meant that if the third party did not recover at least as much as they paid to my company that we would owe them the difference in cash plus interest!

Are there conditions under which I would sell a claim in bankruptcy?  Sure.  One would be if my employer was in a cash crunch and needed the money sooner rather than later.   In my opinion, the costs and risks normally outweigh the benefits.  One of those risks is the boilerplate terms in the sales contract.  I understand why a creditor would be reluctant to spend the money to have an attorney review a contract involving a customer that has already filed for bankruptcy protection and has already cost them money.  To me, the money spent on a legal opinion in this scenario is a necessary evil.

Michael Dennis, CBF

Do you still want to sell your claim in bankruptcy?  Don’t let me discourage you from doing so but please make sure that you do so with your eyes open knowing all the facts and understanding all the risks and ramifications.   In this situation, don’t just look a gift horse in the mouth, start counting his teeth.

Michael Dennis’ Covering Credit Commentary. Michael’s website is at www.coveringcredit.com.  

 

The opinions presented are those of the author.  The opinions and recommendations do not necessarily reflect the views of CMA, or their Officers and Directors.  Readers are encouraged to evaluate any suggestions or recommendations made, and accept and adopt only those concepts that make sense to them.

7 Replies to “Bird In The Hand? – Selling Bankruptcy Claims – Michael Dennis, CBF”

  1. Thanks Michael for the comments on this subject, they confirm my gut sense when approached a couple of times to sell our claims.

  2. I wish there were an easier way to determine the best course of action in collecting on an account in bankruptcy…or a standard operating procedure to follow. Do you send it to a collection agency? Do you just file the proof of claim yourself? Do you sell the claim? Too many options to make it easy and each case seems to be so different. I guess that is why companies hire credit professionals to make those decisions. Job security!?!

  3. Thanks for enlightening us about the potential hidden dangers of these agreements and the suggestions on how to approach them when we do use them.

  4. I agree with your analysis of this situation. I have had the same argument with managment about why we should not sell our claim. The only time I argued to sell our claim was when I the company I was with at the time was experiencing a cash crunch, and then it was helpful. Good post.

  5. Thanks everyone for your response. Selling your claim is a tough decision… But if it was easy, anyone could do it.

    Michael Dennis

  6. Michael,

    Do you have any experiences in having a dollar offer to sell your claim versus what you ultimately received? I don’t know if there is an “average” discount amount but knowing what the anticipated loss might be would assist any decision on whether or not to sell. Especially after factoring in the waiting time. Thanks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *